Boy there is nothing better to light a fire under ones ass than a clear cut double standard. We have all been witness to double standards; women often complain that men get better pay for similar work because of their sex, Blacks often complain that they are treated more harshly by the justice system than whites, and athletics though a valuable means to a college education is devalued beyond compare.
Athletes are being cheated, cheated by a double standard that is sickening and needs to be discussed.
Have any of you out there heard about the Nickleby program?
Yes well it’s very cute; it’s the government’s way of giving kids a fair shot (As they see it) at success. Basically under the Nickleby if you are a student who attends an "F" school you can legally transfer to any "C" or better school of your choice without repercussions; meaning that you would be eligible for all activities and athletics at your school of choice. That is fine and dandy, I don’t have a problem with that; I actually find it to be a positive development, because no one should be made to attend an institution that is underperforming. Everyone has the right to a better opportunity, and if that means you can find that opportunity at another school, then so be it.
But let’s get to the double standard shall we?
Why are athletics not considered just like academics in this situation? Every year hundreds of millions of dollars are awarded for Athletic scholarships, meaning that there are abundant opportunities for students to better themselves through athletics, but first they have to showcase their abilities. However, unlike with the Nickleby, a student that is at a school whose athletic programs are a joke or an “F” in athletics has no recourse to pick up and go elsewhere without repercussion. An athlete who transfers for athletic purposes is accosted and sanctioned by the system; he can lose a year or more of eligibility; and his future can be seriously impacted by this unfair and obvious double standard. I understand academics is important, but for many so are athletics, and in some cases just as if not more important.
Now before you get all bent out of shape, let me explain myself. Some kids go to school and sacrifice, study hard, and attend their classes, because of athletics. Without athletics, many students (especially males) would lack the motivation to keep up with their studies and their attendance; this is a reality. Athletes perform better on exams, have better attendance, get better grades, and are less likely to be detrimental in their behavior to the school environment than the general population of the school. These are facts according to the statistics compiled by the schools themselves.
Why should any athlete in any program be forced to attend a school where their sport of choice at that school would offer less than an adequate opportunity to maximize their potential and skill?
Why should their future be impacted so seriously because the system improperly objectifies athletics, when in fact athletes are proven to excel in the classroom and in the school environment beyond the performance of the average student?
Why are the opportunities that athletics offer less pertinent and receive less consideration than do academics?
I say it’s time to evaluate schools and their athletic programs, grade them based on their performance much as we do with schools on the FCAT, and if a school is found to be lacking in a sport, then their athletes should be allowed to transfer to a school of choice without penalty.
Of course we all know this is a pipe dream, and it will never happen. Therefore, heed the words of the Spiderman, if your want your child to have success in athletics and he belongs to a school who devalues his sport of choice, do everything you can to get him to a schools with an adequate program.
Cheat if you have to, your child’s future is more important than the rules that are biased against them.
Athletes are being cheated, cheated by a double standard that is sickening and needs to be discussed.
Have any of you out there heard about the Nickleby program?
Yes well it’s very cute; it’s the government’s way of giving kids a fair shot (As they see it) at success. Basically under the Nickleby if you are a student who attends an "F" school you can legally transfer to any "C" or better school of your choice without repercussions; meaning that you would be eligible for all activities and athletics at your school of choice. That is fine and dandy, I don’t have a problem with that; I actually find it to be a positive development, because no one should be made to attend an institution that is underperforming. Everyone has the right to a better opportunity, and if that means you can find that opportunity at another school, then so be it.
But let’s get to the double standard shall we?
Why are athletics not considered just like academics in this situation? Every year hundreds of millions of dollars are awarded for Athletic scholarships, meaning that there are abundant opportunities for students to better themselves through athletics, but first they have to showcase their abilities. However, unlike with the Nickleby, a student that is at a school whose athletic programs are a joke or an “F” in athletics has no recourse to pick up and go elsewhere without repercussion. An athlete who transfers for athletic purposes is accosted and sanctioned by the system; he can lose a year or more of eligibility; and his future can be seriously impacted by this unfair and obvious double standard. I understand academics is important, but for many so are athletics, and in some cases just as if not more important.
Now before you get all bent out of shape, let me explain myself. Some kids go to school and sacrifice, study hard, and attend their classes, because of athletics. Without athletics, many students (especially males) would lack the motivation to keep up with their studies and their attendance; this is a reality. Athletes perform better on exams, have better attendance, get better grades, and are less likely to be detrimental in their behavior to the school environment than the general population of the school. These are facts according to the statistics compiled by the schools themselves.
Why should any athlete in any program be forced to attend a school where their sport of choice at that school would offer less than an adequate opportunity to maximize their potential and skill?
Why should their future be impacted so seriously because the system improperly objectifies athletics, when in fact athletes are proven to excel in the classroom and in the school environment beyond the performance of the average student?
Why are the opportunities that athletics offer less pertinent and receive less consideration than do academics?
I say it’s time to evaluate schools and their athletic programs, grade them based on their performance much as we do with schools on the FCAT, and if a school is found to be lacking in a sport, then their athletes should be allowed to transfer to a school of choice without penalty.
Of course we all know this is a pipe dream, and it will never happen. Therefore, heed the words of the Spiderman, if your want your child to have success in athletics and he belongs to a school who devalues his sport of choice, do everything you can to get him to a schools with an adequate program.
Cheat if you have to, your child’s future is more important than the rules that are biased against them.
24 comments:
Spidey,
There is one more critera that you forgot about the No Child Left Behind transfer. The school that he wishes to attend has to be underenrolled. Also, only certain schools in each of the 6 regions are designated so that they get free transportation.
KW,
I may be wrong and I will have to do a little research to find out, but I think schools are not considered over enrolled until they are at 115% capacity.
Currently, there are very few schools in Dade County that are over enrolled even if over enrolled were 100% capacity. The real-estate market and the cost of living have actually had quite the effect on enrollment. Many schools have had to surplus teachers and such, so I think pretty much every school would be able to accept a Nickleby transfer.
Lastly, you are correct on the transportation issue, but provided that a student can be responsible for their own transportation, they may attend any school of their choice.
The point is if you have the right network in place, your team can get pretty strong pretty quickly. South West Football started out the season 4 and 0 and I think they have since improved. I scarcely remember them ever having more than one or two black players on their team, but this year they have around 17 or so, can you see the correlation?
I have issues with the whole transfering thing because it would eventually lead to a whole new dilema. When do you say No to people. If they can transfer because their school is an F school then they can transfer because of their religious beliefs (to a private school and have the government pay for it), now to athletics and then to the idea of wanting to go to a rich school instead of a poor school. Just because those schools have more field trips or have better something or other.
Moonie,
A free market is always better. The more regulated the more corrupt. As it stands, only schools with the resources, the money, and the connections are able to bring in the wrestlers to win the titles. Just look at the big board and you will see that year in and year out the same teams dominate because they are better equipped to circumvent the system. If it were a free and open market, everyone could do the same business, there is a finite number of good individuals one school can have before those individuals start looking to go elsewhere, no wrestler wants to be behind another for 2 years when they can possibly get 4 years as a starter. Deregulating will spread the wealth, all the regulations in the world are not going to keep Oviedo and Brandon from bringing in the talent they need to get the job done.
I must say I agree with the Spider on this one, it seems that the same Kennels are always winning best in show Overall Kennel of distinction. Some might think that it’s because they have the best Dog trainers, and while it is certainly the case that those trainers are indeed among the best, there are many other trainers just as equipped to train champions but they rarely get the Dogs with the champion blood lines. Many times in fact trainers with less notoriety do a better job because they deal with Dogs that are completely new to the circuit, dogs that have just started to compete and have little if any experience in shows. Those are the real trainers, the ones that make their champions from scratch, the ones that surprises everyone and leave you wondering where the heck they came from. Like the Spider said, there are only so many Rottweillers one Kennel can have; there are Kennels out there that could take those other Rottweillers looking for an opportunity and make them into champion dogs as well, but because of the rules preventing them from changing kennels, they are stuck with lesser trainers in kennels that might not care as much about the dog show as they do about other things like home protection. Dogs should be free to move to a kennel that can make them champions, and it is the responsibility of their owners to see that they make that happen.
Always nice to hear from PWD.
Thanks for the support.
Southwest is a combination of NICLB and Finance MAGNET. The football team is 5 - 2, (they were never undefeated, they lost to South Dade in the very first game.) Braddock is 6 - 1 and the game next week could very well be for the District Championship between Southwest and Braddock.
I can think of several schools that are over enrolled. South Dade, Braddock are just 2 to name. I think Ferguson and Varela are also overenrolled. I'm pretty sure that Sunset is the designated NICLB transportation school in the West Kendall Region.
KW,
Thanks for the corrections, I don't foolow football as much, so that was an honest mistake on my part. Is overenrollement then at 115% capacity or not, I am not 100% on that one either.
Thanks!
Spider, you have some mail I would like you to look at. Let me know what you think.
Gimme a few minutes.
Moonie,
That was a lot to digest, give me some time to reply, lest I reply hastily and not return the information you seek. Be patient.
Thank you Spider. Much to your dismay I am really a patient person. the simple fact that I use this forum instead of just going to your lair show my patience does it not?
Moonie,
Your box is hot.
so is yours webhead.
You pose a dilemma,Spidey.While free market works in business it does not work in education where the goal is to educate all the students.We have seen people try to implement business models in schools and it doesn't work.As far as athletics you would have to deal with issues of extreme inequalities in sports teams.How would you deal with this.
Galactus,
You have stumbled on my dilema. What happens to those programs that are just trying to start or are facing some troubled times. By releasing their best athletes those schools may be doing too much damage to ever recover from. How do we stop kids from transfering to South Dade or to other schools that have great programs who need just one more kid to win it all. What happens to those programs who lose the one reason the school uses to promote the sport. very difficult if you ask me.
Spider,
You have the reply to the mail you sent me.
Galactus,
Like I said before, there is a finite number of exceptional wrestlers a school can carry. I understand you reservations, but what you are talking about happens anyway, if SD needs a kid they get him. Freedom is always better, and regulations always seem to be more beneficial to the cheaters than to those who follow the rules. If there were an open enrollment policy, the wealth would be more easily spread than as it stands because as it stands only thw schools with power and influence can benefit.
Spider,
You are correct in what you say but those schools need just one kid. Other schools have just ONE kid. To lose that one kid who makes the team worth trying out for is devastating. I understand that kids need a right to move to a better program if theirs in not up to par but the consequences are real and could hurt athletics in a major way in the long run.
Moonie,
I guess we can agree to disagree then.
BTW you have mail
Moonie,
I guess we can agree to disagree then.
BTW you have mail
Spider,
It is not as easy as agree to disagree. There must be someone out there who can come up with a way in which kids that have sucky coaches can move to schools that have better programs and opportunities. That does not mean that ALL the great wrestlers in the state should go to one school or the other. I think there should be a limit to the schools that a kid can go to. Maybe they can transfer to a school within their own district. That may be a way in which to do it.
Any time something is regulated, you will have abuse due to influence, position, and financing. The haves will always find a way, the only way to include the have nots is to open it up for all.
Spidey
P.S. I dig the new avatar
The possibility,nay reality, of the most powerful schools increasing in strength is most certain, leaving other schools in thei dust as happens under a total free market.Checks and balances are necessary although the clowns now in charge do a piss poor job.Where is teddy 'Trust Buster'Roosevelt when you need him?
Post a Comment